Thursday, April 03, 2008

Logo much? Coach lip gloss.


I don't think logoed items should be automatically scorned or dismissed. Louis Vuitton is an iconic brand because of their monogram canvas bags which have spawned countless imitators. I object primarily to ugly logos and the lazy use of logos as it imparts a false sense of value to products -- a tea cosy embroidered with Chanel's interlocking c's isn't going to make a pot of Lipton taste like Mariage Freres. By succumbing to such cheap and blatant branding practices, consumers encourage manufacturers to be complacent and unimaginative.

There's branding, and there's lazy branding. These Coach lip glosses smack of the latter -- the logo is all over the tube like a bad rash. The packaging signals to me that Coach couldn't be bothered to come up with a distinctive product, and like the Coach perfume, the glosses seem as though they were manufactured to steal the few remaining dollars from the purses of their most blinkered customers. "Our customers aren't Hermes customers," you can hear them arguing in the boardroom. "They don't expect top quality, and since they're not paying Hermes prices, we're not going to give them top quality either. Oh, just whip up some gunk, stuff 'em in these containers we bought in China and stamp our logo on it to make them look Coach-y."

The Coach lip glosses come in three shades -- Gardenia, Hibiscus and Heather -- and retails for US$22 on its website. I recommend that you purchase a Guerlain Kiss Kiss gloss, Chanel Glossimer or YSL Golden Gloss for real lip gloss snob factor, if that's what you're after. Even if it's a dumb reason to buy a gloss.

5 comments:

Tine said...

Ugh, talk about overkill. Looks very cheapo. I do agree, a YSL would be a real snob gloss ;)

Shryh said...

This is a case where the brand clearly comes before the product. Maybe the gloss formulation is excellent, but I'd be embarrassed to be seen using that tube in public lest people think I'm a brand whore. Oh, and ditto that on the YSL. ;)

jojoba said...

I can't agree more! I used to like Coach but its products have been going down the drain since the huge logo came out. and now it wants a share in makeup! WTF! (sorry!) Leave makeup alone!

jojoba said...

I can't agree more! I used to like Coach but its products have been going down the drain since the huge logo came out. and now it wants a share in makeup! WTF! (sorry!) Leave makeup alone!

prettypeanut said...

I received this set as a gift and the lip gloss is really good quality. It's not sticky like some of the other major brands out there. Try it before you knock it!